Home
Jewelry
Rings
New Items!
Pendants and Necklaces
New Items!
Earrings
New Items!
Bracelets and Anklets
New Items!
Enamel Pins
Feather Ear Cuffs
Barrettes and Hair Sticks
Tikkas
Witchy Jewelry
New Items!
Moon Jewelry
Celtic Jewelry
Tree Jewelry
Dragon Jewelry
Gemstone Jewelry
New Items!
Magical Supplies
Candles
Crystals and Gemstones
New Items!
Pagan Altar Accessories
Pendulums
Resin Incense
Sage and Herbs
New Items!
Express Yourself
Leatherbound Journals
Enamel Pins
Blank Greeting Cards
Birthday Cards
Yule & Christmas Cards
Tin Signs
Window Stickers
Bumper Stickers
Clothing
Handmade Cloaks
Moon Phase Cloaks
T-Shirts
Witch Hats
For Your Home
Meditation Banners
Holiday Ornaments
Kitchen Accessories
Statuary
Suncatchers
Tin Signs
Wall Hooks
Window Stickers
Craft Supplies
All Cross Stitch Patterns
New Items!
Embroidery Scissors
Pagan Cross Stitch Patterns
New Items!
Celtic Cross Stitch Patterns
Dragon Cross Stitch Patterns
Themes
Moons
Dragons
Goddesses
New Items!
Ravens
Cats
Norse / Viking
Owls
Pentacles (And Stars)
New Items!
Creatures of the Night
Hearts & Romance
Butterflies & Dragonflies
Samhain / Halloween
Yule / Christmas
Trees & Greenman
New Items
By Price Range
Sale
Cross Stitch Pattern Clearance 25% to 75% Off
Spring Goddess Statuette Sale
Clearance
Bargain Bundles
Login / View Wishlist
Library of Articles
About Us
Your source of everyday magic for over 25 years.
$7 Shipping. Free over $100.
Shop
Your source of everyday magic for over 25 years.
$7 Shipping. Free over $100.
Library
Wishlist
View Cart
-
0
items in cart
Jewelry
Rings
New Items!
Pendants and Necklaces
New Items!
Earrings
New Items!
Bracelets and Anklets
New Items!
Enamel Pins
Feather Ear Cuffs
Barrettes and Hair Sticks
Tikkas
Witchy Jewelry
New Items!
Moon Jewelry
Celtic Jewelry
Tree Jewelry
Dragon Jewelry
Gemstone Jewelry
New Items!
Magical Supplies
Candles
Crystals and Gemstones
New Items!
Pagan Altar Accessories
Pendulums
Resin Incense
Sage and Herbs
New Items!
Express Yourself
Leatherbound Journals
Enamel Pins
Blank Greeting Cards
Birthday Cards
Yule & Christmas Cards
Tin Signs
Window Stickers
Bumper Stickers
Clothing
Handmade Cloaks
Moon Phase Cloaks
T-Shirts
Witch Hats
For Your Home
Meditation Banners
Holiday Ornaments
Kitchen Accessories
Statuary
Suncatchers
Tin Signs
Wall Hooks
Window Stickers
Craft Supplies
All Cross Stitch Patterns
New Items!
Embroidery Scissors
Pagan Cross Stitch Patterns
New Items!
Celtic Cross Stitch Patterns
Dragon Cross Stitch Patterns
Themes
Moons
Dragons
Goddesses
New Items!
Ravens
Cats
Norse / Viking
Owls
Pentacles (And Stars)
New Items!
Creatures of the Night
Hearts & Romance
Butterflies & Dragonflies
Samhain / Halloween
Yule / Christmas
Trees & Greenman
New Items
By Price Range
Sale
Cross Stitch Pattern Clearance 25% to 75% Off
Spring Goddess Statuette Sale
Clearance
Bargain Bundles
Showing results for:
Make Pin
Don't see what you're looking for? Try these related searches…
Make (503)
Pin (145)
Make Pin (58 items)
Clearance!
"Maker" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Crystal Ball Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Hedgehog Heart Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Hedgehog Puzzle Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Pink Pistol Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Slightly Bitter Lemon Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Corgi Flop Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Corgi Butt Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Live Long & Pawspurr" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Large Penguin Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Bananya Cat Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
"Do No Harm" Snake Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
She/Her Pronouns Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
He/Him Pronouns Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
They/Them Pronouns Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Go Away I'm Busy" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Moon Child Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Black Like My Soul" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Midnight Moth Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Snowy Owl Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Hot Pink Feather Dangle Wire Ear Cuff
Was
$10.00
-
now
$
8.00
Add to Cart
Sage and Pine Herb Bundle
$
5.00
or 3 for $13.00
Choose Option
▸
Pink Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Sage Bundle Sampler II
$
12.00
Add to Cart
Herbal Magic Courage Pillar Candle
$
12.50
Add to Cart
Herbal Magic Courage Votive Candle
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Herbal Magic Confidence Votive Candle
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Herbal Magic Manifest a Miracle Pillar Candle
$
12.50
Add to Cart
Herbal Magic Love Votive Candle
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Star Tea Infuser
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Celtic Dragon Tea Infuser
$
14.00
Out of Stock
▸
Dragon Flight Tea Infuser
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Dark Grey Viking Cloak with Trim
$
85.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Tawny Gold Viking-Style Cloak with Trim
$
85.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Flying Dragon Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Faux Ivory Beaded Fantasy Headpiece
Was
$8.00
-
now
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Turquoise Teardrop Fantasy Headpiece
Was
$8.00
-
now
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Gold Disk Fantasy Headpiece
Was
$8.00
-
now
$
4.00
Add to Cart
New!
Silver Domed Pentacle Earrings
$
17.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Peekaboo Cat Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Fucupcakes Tin Sign
$
19.00
Add to Cart
Silver Winged Skull Ring
$
38.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Rainbow Moonstone Scroll Necklace
$
72.00
Add to Cart
Pure Magic Yule Card
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Silver Wings Pendant
$
54.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Silver Coin Fantasy Headpiece
Was
$18.00
-
now
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Copper Coin Fantasy Headpiece
Was
$18.00
-
now
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Silver Victorian Amethyst Ring
$
26.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Four Quarters Celtic Pendant
$
25.00
Add to Cart
"Touch of Silver" Ring
$
20.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Rose Ring
$
21.00
Choose Size
▸
Rose Gold Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Goddess Tea Infuser
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Tumbled Rhodonite Gemstones
$
12.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Amber Ring
$
45.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Lotus Flower Pendant
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Natural Himalayan Salt Chunks
$
5.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Moon Pendant
$
25.00
Out of Stock
▸