Home
Jewelry
Rings
New Items!
Pendants and Necklaces
New Items!
Earrings
New Items!
Bracelets and Anklets
New Items!
Enamel Pins
Feather Ear Cuffs
Barrettes and Hair Sticks
Tikkas
Witchy Jewelry
New Items!
Moon Jewelry
New Items!
Celtic Jewelry
Tree Jewelry
Dragon Jewelry
Gemstone Jewelry
New Items!
Magical Supplies
Candles
Crystals and Gemstones
New Items!
Pagan Altar Accessories
Pendulums
Resin Incense
Sage and Herbs
New Items!
Express Yourself
Leatherbound Journals
Enamel Pins
Blank Greeting Cards
Birthday Cards
Yule & Christmas Cards
Tin Signs
Window Stickers
Bumper Stickers
Clothing
Handmade Cloaks
Moon Phase Cloaks
T-Shirts
Witch Hats
For Your Home
Meditation Banners
Holiday Ornaments
Kitchen Accessories
Statuary
Suncatchers
Tin Signs
Wall Hooks
Window Stickers
Craft Supplies
All Cross Stitch Patterns
Embroidery Scissors
Pagan Cross Stitch Patterns
Celtic Cross Stitch Patterns
Dragon Cross Stitch Patterns
Themes
Moons
Dragons
Goddesses
New Items!
Ravens
Cats
Norse / Viking
Owls
Pentacles (And Stars)
New Items!
Creatures of the Night
Hearts & Romance
Butterflies & Dragonflies
Samhain / Halloween
Yule / Christmas
Trees & Greenman
New Items
By Price Range
Sale
Votive Candles
Spring Goddess Statuette
Clearance
Bargain Bundles
Login / View Wishlist
Library of Articles
About Us
Votive Candle Sale - 25% Off
Your source of everyday magic for over 25 years.
$7 Shipping. Free over $100.
Shop
Your source of everyday magic for over 25 years.
$7 Shipping. Free over $100.
Library
Wishlist
View Cart
-
0
items in cart
Jewelry
Rings
New Items!
Pendants and Necklaces
New Items!
Earrings
New Items!
Bracelets and Anklets
New Items!
Enamel Pins
Feather Ear Cuffs
Barrettes and Hair Sticks
Tikkas
Witchy Jewelry
New Items!
Moon Jewelry
New Items!
Celtic Jewelry
Tree Jewelry
Dragon Jewelry
Gemstone Jewelry
New Items!
Magical Supplies
Candles
Crystals and Gemstones
New Items!
Pagan Altar Accessories
Pendulums
Resin Incense
Sage and Herbs
New Items!
Express Yourself
Leatherbound Journals
Enamel Pins
Blank Greeting Cards
Birthday Cards
Yule & Christmas Cards
Tin Signs
Window Stickers
Bumper Stickers
Clothing
Handmade Cloaks
Moon Phase Cloaks
T-Shirts
Witch Hats
For Your Home
Meditation Banners
Holiday Ornaments
Kitchen Accessories
Statuary
Suncatchers
Tin Signs
Wall Hooks
Window Stickers
Craft Supplies
All Cross Stitch Patterns
Embroidery Scissors
Pagan Cross Stitch Patterns
Celtic Cross Stitch Patterns
Dragon Cross Stitch Patterns
Themes
Moons
Dragons
Goddesses
New Items!
Ravens
Cats
Norse / Viking
Owls
Pentacles (And Stars)
New Items!
Creatures of the Night
Hearts & Romance
Butterflies & Dragonflies
Samhain / Halloween
Yule / Christmas
Trees & Greenman
New Items
By Price Range
Sale
Votive Candles
Spring Goddess Statuette
Clearance
Bargain Bundles
Showing results for:
can't to
Don't see what you're looking for? Try these related searches…
can't (250)
to (795)
can't to (250 items)
Lavender Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Pink Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Rose Gold Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Apple Green Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Green Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Metallic Green Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
6.00
Add to Cart
On Sale!
French Vanilla Votive Candle
Was
$3.00
-
now
$
2.25
Add to Cart
Multicolor Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Gold Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Orange Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Brown Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Sky Blue Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Blue Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
White Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Purple Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Pearl White Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Red Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Black Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Silver Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Yellow Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Metallic Red Mini Chime Ritual Spell Candles
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Yin/Yang Tree T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
Thor's Hammer T-Shirt
$
18.00
Choose Size
▸
The Witching Hour T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
A Brush With Magic T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
The Spell Keeper T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
Gothic Guardian T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
Celtic Roots T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
Awake Your Magic T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Dragon T-Shirt
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
"I can only please ONE person…" Bumper Sticker
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Don't Be a Dick" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Bargain Bundle #7
$
25.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Bargain Bundle #10
$
25.00
Add to Cart
Natural Himalayan Salt Chunks
$
5.00
Add to Cart
Tumbled Obsidian Gemstones
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Celtic Aura Ring
Was
$22.00
-
now
$
16.50
Choose Size
▸
I'm Not Quiet - I'm Plotting Tin Sign
$
19.00
Add to Cart
Silver Honeybee Spoon Ring
$
31.00
Choose Size
▸
Snow Kitten Greeting Card
$
4.50
Add to Cart
"Caution! I brake for Elves…" Bumper Sticker
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Golden Feathered Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Silver Tree Pendant
$
32.00
Add to Cart
Silver Tree Ring
$
24.00
Choose Size
▸
Steel Rainbow Pawprint Ring
$
15.00
Choose Size
▸
Limited
Celtic Hair Comb
$
30.00
Add to Cart
Blue Butterflies Band
$
21.00
Choose Size
▸
Clearance!
"Who Are These Kids…" Bumper Sticker
Was
$2.00
-
now
$
0.50
Add to Cart
Butterfly Dream Window Sticker
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Christmas Train Snowflake Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Phoenix and Dragon Embroidery Scissors
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Wheel of the Year Wooden Yule Ornament
$
18.00
Add to Cart
Silver Moonstone Triquetra Pentacle Pendant
$
67.00
Add to Cart
Tree of Life Wall Hook
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Key Pendant
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Stitch and Stash Cross Stitch Pattern
Was
$7.00
-
now
$
5.25
Add to Cart
Dragonlet's Birth Sampler Cross Stitch Pattern
$
12.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"I Read Banned Books" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Corgi Flop Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Oops" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Boss Witch Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Yin/Yang Cats Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Go Away I'm Busy" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Mercury Retrograde Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Dragon Wall Hook
$
23.00
Add to Cart
New!
Silver Eternal Goddess Pendant
$
84.00
Add to Cart
Sage & Eucalyptus Herb Bundle
$
5.00
or 3 for $13.00
Choose Option
▸
Sage and Pine Herb Bundle
$
5.00
or 3 for $13.00
Choose Option
▸
Silver Celtic Passion Necklace
$
114.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Small Turkey Feathers
Was
$2.00
-
now
$
1.60
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Blue/Black Duck Feathers
Was
$2.00
-
now
$
1.60
Add to Cart
Copper Mini Wand Divination Pendulum
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Grinning Skull Umbrella
Was
$22.00
-
now
$
14.96
Add to Cart
Large Selenite Wand
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Small Selenite Wand
$
11.00
Add to Cart
Tumbled Serpentine Gemstones
$
10.00
Add to Cart
Silver Prancing Unicorn Post Earrings
$
16.00
Add to Cart
Silver Dragonfly Post Earrings
$
16.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Knot Post Earrings
$
17.00
Add to Cart
Silver Owl Ring
$
26.00
Choose Size
▸
Yuletide Angel Yule Card
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Silver Labradorite Pentacle Ring
$
32.00
Choose Size
▸
Stainless Steel Sweetheart Solitaire Ring
$
21.00
Choose Size
▸
Solstice Gathering Yule Card
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Enchanted Garden Ring
$
20.00
Choose Size
▸
Save a Life - Send Fabric Tin Sign
$
19.00
Add to Cart
Silver Labradorite Dragon's Claw Ring
$
85.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Filigree Celtic Ring
$
21.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Rose Ring
$
21.00
Choose Size
▸
Wear Black Tin Sign
$
19.00
Add to Cart
Vigilant Gryphon Statue
$
42.00
Add to Cart
Silver Coiled Dragon Pendant
$
25.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Unicorn Ring
Was
$16.00
-
now
$
12.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Triskele Signet Ring
$
29.00
Choose Size
▸
Fire Dragon Greeting Card
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Silver Sapphire Celtic Ring
$
40.00
Choose Size
▸
Limited
Peekaboo Cat Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Silver Four Quarters Celtic Pendant
$
25.00
Add to Cart
Silver Stag's Head Ring
$
19.00
Choose Size
▸
Limited
Silver Double Path Celtic Band
$
35.00
Choose Size
▸
Realm of Tranquility Greeting Card
$
4.50
Add to Cart
The Witching Hour Cross Stitch Pattern
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Silver Crystal Moon Pendant
$
61.00
Add to Cart
Books, Wine, Cat Tin Sign
$
19.00
Add to Cart
Moon Goddess Wooden Yule Ornament
$
18.00
Add to Cart
Silver Bat Post Earrings
$
17.00
Add to Cart
Red Witch Hat
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Black Witch Hat
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Light Grey Witch Hat
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Navy Witch Hat
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Dark Grey Witch Hat
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Ancient Warrior Steel Ring
$
27.00
Choose Size
▸
Triple Moon Dish
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Purple Witch Hat
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Silver Pentacle Post Earrings
$
16.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Creekbed Maple Leather Journal
$
62.00
Choose Size
▸
Pocket Goddess
$
3.00
Choose Option
▸
Frankincense and Myrrh Resin Incense
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Enchanted Forest Window Sticker
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Silver Crystal Moon Earrings
$
36.00
Add to Cart
Silver Triple Moon Pendant with Mother of Pearl
$
54.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
White Feather Wire Ear Cuff
Was
$10.00
-
now
$
8.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Black Feather Wire Ear Cuff
Was
$10.00
-
now
$
8.00
Add to Cart
Silver Owl with Bone Pentacle Pendant
$
58.00
Add to Cart
Moon Phase Ring
$
17.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Celtic Onyx Men's Ring
$
80.00
Choose Size
▸
Frankincense Resin Incense
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Myrrh Resin Incense
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Purple Feathered Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Silver Pegasus Post Earrings
$
16.00
Add to Cart
Dragon's Blood Resin Incense
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Zig Zag Zest Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Spider Web Witch Hat in Red
$
45.00
Add to Cart
"Caffeine System" Bumper Sticker
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Silver Garnet Trinity Knot Pendant
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Silver Faerie Pentacle Necklace
$
103.00
Out of Stock
▸
Limited
Luna Moth Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Dragons Ring
$
60.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Winged Skull Ring
$
38.00
Choose Size
▸
"Literary Owl" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Silver Dancing Dragon Post Earrings
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Silver Owl Goddess Pendant
$
63.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Black Moon Phase Cloak with Hood
Was
$72.00
-
now
$
36.00
Choose Size
▸
Clearance!
Purple Moon Phase Cloak with Hood
Was
$72.00
-
now
$
36.00
Choose Size
▸
Triquetra Wooden Yule Ornament
$
18.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Midnight Moonflower Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
On Sale!
Spring Goddess Statuette
Was
$24.00
-
now
$
17.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Silver Crossed Hearts Puzzle Ring
Was
$27.00
-
now
$
20.25
Choose Size
▸
Silver Petite Celtic Butterfly Pendant
$
29.00
Add to Cart
Silver Boho Tribal Ring
$
27.00
Choose Size
▸
Limited
Snowman Christmas Tree Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Moonstone Ring
$
40.00
Choose Size
▸
Limited
Celtic Cross Christmas Tree Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Irish Shamrock Christmas Tree Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Scottish Thistle Christmas Tree Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Butterfly Pendant
$
79.00
Choose Gem
▸
Limited
Christmas Trees Snowflake Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Butterfly Ring
$
47.00
Choose Size
▸
Celtic Cat Wall Hook
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Signs of Peace Window Sticker
$
4.00
Add to Cart
Silver Crescent Raven Pendant
$
57.00
Add to Cart
Chester Gargoyle Statue
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Silver Enchantment Ring
$
25.00
Choose Size
▸
Silver Vine Ring
$
21.00
Choose Size
▸
Limited
Snowflake Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Silver Lotus Flower Pendant
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Flying Dragon Witch Hat
$
45.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Cat Lover's Christmas Tree Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Raven Wall Hook
$
23.00
Out of Stock
▸
Sherwood Gargoyle Statue
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Forest Magic Christmas Tree Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
New!
Silver Domed Pentacle Earrings
$
17.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Claddagh Christmas Tree Ornament
$
15.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Silver Pagan Handfasting Ring
Was
$38.00
-
now
$
28.50
Choose Size
▸
Silver Tree of Life Ring
$
40.00
Choose Size
▸
"Magic, Happy, Wild & Free" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Silver Pentacle Pendant w/ Tiger Eye
$
21.00
Add to Cart
Silver Pentacle Earrings w/ Tiger Eye
$
28.00
Add to Cart
Silver Nocturnal Symphony Necklace
$
233.00
Add to Cart
"No Late Knight Snacking" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
6.00
Out of Stock
▸
Not Forgotten Cross Stitch Pattern
$
12.00
Out of Stock
▸
Celtic Cat Cross Stitch Pattern
$
11.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Butterfly Earrings
$
41.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Fire Ring
$
60.00
Choose Size
▸
"Wild One" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Coffee Haus Chester Statue
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Silver Heart Poison Ring
$
41.00
Choose Size
▸
Christmas Star Cross Stitch Pattern
$
11.00
Add to Cart
Faraway Cross Stitch Pattern
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Pentacle Pendulum Mat
$
11.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Silver Celtic Spirals and Knots Poison Ring
Was
$38.00
-
now
$
28.50
Choose Size
▸
Lost Dragon Sampler Cross Stitch Pattern
$
12.00
Out of Stock
▸
"My Cauldron" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Spells Cast Here" Cross Stitch Pattern
Was
$6.00
-
now
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Celtic Christmas Angel Cross Stitch Pattern
$
11.00
Add to Cart
Silver Garnet Eye Ring
$
18.00
Choose Size
▸
Hidden Chamber Divination Pendulum with Copper and Brass Accents
$
9.00
Add to Cart
"What the Cat Saw: Close Encounters" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
11.00
Add to Cart
Winged Lion Plaque
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Gryphon Plaque
$
14.00
Add to Cart
The Spell Keeper Cross Stitch Pattern
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Triple Moon Copper Bowl
$
18.00
Add to Cart
Pentacle Copper Bowl
$
18.00
Add to Cart
"Beneath the Harvest Moon" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
13.00
Add to Cart
"Witch Switch" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
5.50
Add to Cart
"What the Cat Saw: Bigfoot" Cross Stitch Pattern
$
11.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Silver "Síorghrá" Celtic Ring
$
42.00
Choose Size
▸
Limited
Golden Brown Full Circle Cloak
$
135.00
Add to Cart
Stainless Steel Crescent Moon Anklet
$
10.00
Add to Cart
Stainless Steel Pentacle Anklet
$
10.00
Add to Cart
Stainless Steel Peace Sign Anklet
$
10.00
Add to Cart
Dani the Stitching Dragon Cross Stitch Pattern
$
12.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Navy and Green Half-Circle Cloak
$
90.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Olive Brown Half-Circle Cloak with Hood
$
95.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Grey Striped Full Circle Cloak with Hood and Pockets
$
145.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Olive Brown Full Circle Cloak
$
120.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Brown Full Circle Cloak with Hood and Trim
$
145.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Halloween Cat Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
"Stitch 'n Witch" Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Just Peachy" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Lady Luck d20 Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Music Cat Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Tea Drinking Kermit Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
She/Her Pronouns Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
He/Him Pronouns Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
They/Them Pronouns Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Hedgehog Heart Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Hedgehog Puzzle Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"The Book Was Better" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Safe With Me" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Pink Pistol Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Just Visiting Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
"Books Are Magic" Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Tarot Cards Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Misadventure Awaits d20 Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Kitsune Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Swift Lite Charcoal
$
3.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Princess/Scientist Enamel Pin
Was
$9.00
-
now
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Bat Wall Hook
$
23.00
Out of Stock
▸
Demon Coffee Enamel Pin
$
9.00
Add to Cart
Evil Eye Leather Bracelet
$
14.00
Add to Cart
Cedar Herb Bundle
$
4.00
or 3 for $10.00
Choose Color
▸
Woodland Fantasy Necklace
$
24.00
Add to Cart
Silver Victorian Onyx Pendant
$
27.00
Add to Cart
Silver Victorian Onyx Earrings
$
26.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Celtic Spirals Barrette
$
18.00
Add to Cart
Black and Silver Chevron Ring
$
20.00
Choose Size
▸
Copper & Silver Chevron Ring
$
19.00
Choose Size
▸