Home
Jewelry
Rings
New Items!
Pendants and Necklaces
New Items!
Earrings
New Items!
Bracelets and Anklets
New Items!
Enamel Pins
Feather Ear Cuffs
Barrettes and Hair Sticks
Tikkas
Witchy Jewelry
New Items!
Moon Jewelry
New Items!
Celtic Jewelry
Tree Jewelry
Dragon Jewelry
Gemstone Jewelry
New Items!
Magical Supplies
Candles
Crystals and Gemstones
New Items!
Pagan Altar Accessories
Pendulums
Resin Incense
Sage and Herbs
New Items!
Express Yourself
Leatherbound Journals
Enamel Pins
Blank Greeting Cards
Birthday Cards
Yule & Christmas Cards
Tin Signs
Window Stickers
Bumper Stickers
Clothing
Handmade Cloaks
Moon Phase Cloaks
T-Shirts
Witch Hats
For Your Home
Meditation Banners
Holiday Ornaments
Kitchen Accessories
Statuary
Suncatchers
Tin Signs
Wall Hooks
Window Stickers
Craft Supplies
All Cross Stitch Patterns
Embroidery Scissors
Pagan Cross Stitch Patterns
Celtic Cross Stitch Patterns
Dragon Cross Stitch Patterns
Themes
Moons
Dragons
Goddesses
New Items!
Ravens
Cats
Norse / Viking
Owls
Pentacles (And Stars)
New Items!
Creatures of the Night
Hearts & Romance
Butterflies & Dragonflies
Samhain / Halloween
Yule / Christmas
Trees & Greenman
New Items
By Price Range
Sale
Votive Candles
Spring Goddess Statuette
Clearance
Bargain Bundles
Login / View Wishlist
Library of Articles
About Us
Votive Candle Sale - 25% Off
Your source of everyday magic for over 25 years.
$7 Shipping. Free over $100.
Shop
Your source of everyday magic for over 25 years.
$7 Shipping. Free over $100.
Library
Wishlist
View Cart
-
0
items in cart
Jewelry
Rings
New Items!
Pendants and Necklaces
New Items!
Earrings
New Items!
Bracelets and Anklets
New Items!
Enamel Pins
Feather Ear Cuffs
Barrettes and Hair Sticks
Tikkas
Witchy Jewelry
New Items!
Moon Jewelry
New Items!
Celtic Jewelry
Tree Jewelry
Dragon Jewelry
Gemstone Jewelry
New Items!
Magical Supplies
Candles
Crystals and Gemstones
New Items!
Pagan Altar Accessories
Pendulums
Resin Incense
Sage and Herbs
New Items!
Express Yourself
Leatherbound Journals
Enamel Pins
Blank Greeting Cards
Birthday Cards
Yule & Christmas Cards
Tin Signs
Window Stickers
Bumper Stickers
Clothing
Handmade Cloaks
Moon Phase Cloaks
T-Shirts
Witch Hats
For Your Home
Meditation Banners
Holiday Ornaments
Kitchen Accessories
Statuary
Suncatchers
Tin Signs
Wall Hooks
Window Stickers
Craft Supplies
All Cross Stitch Patterns
Embroidery Scissors
Pagan Cross Stitch Patterns
Celtic Cross Stitch Patterns
Dragon Cross Stitch Patterns
Themes
Moons
Dragons
Goddesses
New Items!
Ravens
Cats
Norse / Viking
Owls
Pentacles (And Stars)
New Items!
Creatures of the Night
Hearts & Romance
Butterflies & Dragonflies
Samhain / Halloween
Yule / Christmas
Trees & Greenman
New Items
By Price Range
Sale
Votive Candles
Spring Goddess Statuette
Clearance
Bargain Bundles
Showing results for:
Make a Wish
Don't see what you're looking for? Try these related searches…
a Wish (215)
Make Wish (99)
Make a (502)
Make (504)
a (796)
Wish (215)
Make a Wish (99 items)
Triquetra Wooden Yule Ornament
$
18.00
Add to Cart
"I'll Make My Own Happy Ending" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
12.00
Add to Cart
One of a Kind
Chocolate Brown Linen-Look Half Circle Cloak
Handmade Cloak -
$
85.00
5
stars
(
4
reviews)
Add to Cart
One of a Kind
Navy and Green Half-Circle Cloak
Handmade Cloak -
$
90.00
5
stars
(
4
reviews)
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 1 left!
Spider Web Witch Hat in Red
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
"May the Roads Rise to Meet You" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
13.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 1 left!
Purple Feathered Witch Hat
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Dragon Virtues Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
15.00
Sorry, temporarily out of stock.
5
stars
(
1
review)
View Item
▸
"May the Wind Be at Your Back" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
13.00
Add to Cart
"Addled Her Brain" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
7.00
Add to Cart
"Beneath the Harvest Moon" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
13.00
Add to Cart
Tumbled Amethyst Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
5.00
5
stars
(
3
reviews)
Add to Cart
Knot Magic Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
7.00
Add to Cart
Sage & Basil Herb Bundle
White Sage and Basil -
$
5.00
or 3 for $13.00
Choose Option
▸
Amethyst Gemstone Lasers
set of 3 stones -
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Cedar Herb Bundle
Cedar -
$
4.00
or 3 for $10.00
Choose Color
▸
Tumbled Fluorite Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
9.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Blessed Be Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Raven Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
Sorry, temporarily out of stock.
View Item
▸
Pentacle Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Tree of Life Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Greenman Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Celtic Knot Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
4.5
stars
(
2
reviews)
Add to Cart
Pagan Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
Add to Cart
Brigid's Cross Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Celtic Cat Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Celtic Tree Wall Hook
Pewter -
$
23.00
Sorry, temporarily out of stock.
5
stars
(
1
review)
View Item
▸
Winter Guardians Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Steampunk Santa Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Winter Owl Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
2
reviews)
Add to Cart
Mistletoe Fairy Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Winter Protector Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Winter Solstice Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
4
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Yule Herne Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Snowflake Fairy Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
3
reviews)
Add to Cart
Little Helpers Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Bright Blessings Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
3
reviews)
Add to Cart
Snow Dragon Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Magical Arrival Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
2
reviews)
Add to Cart
Night Before Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Queen of the Aurora Bears Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Solstice Gathering Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
2
reviews)
Add to Cart
Pure Magic Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Yuletide Angel Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Midnight Messenger Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Spirit of Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
3
reviews)
Add to Cart
Winter Fantasy Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Surprise Gift Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Snow Bringer Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Mr. Hedgely Yule Card
Single Card and Envelope -
$
4.50
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Limited Quantity - Only 1 left!
Stitch and Stash Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
Was
$7.00
- now
$
5.25
Add to Cart
Silver Bat Post Earrings
Sterling Silver -
$
17.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Red Witch Hat
$
21.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Black Witch Hat
$
21.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Light Grey Witch Hat
$
21.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Navy Witch Hat
$
21.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Dark Grey Witch Hat
$
21.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Purple Witch Hat
$
21.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Pair of Gold Stars Mini Candle Holders
Porcelain (set of two) -
$
8.00
5
stars
(
4
reviews)
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Moonstone Ring
Available in sizes
Sizes
4-12
-
Sterling Silver -
$
40.00
5
stars
(
28
reviews)
Choose Size
▸
Tumbled Sodalite Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
3.00
5
stars
(
3
reviews)
Add to Cart
Triple Moon Copper Bowl
$
18.00
Add to Cart
Pentacle Copper Bowl
$
18.00
5
stars
(
2
reviews)
Add to Cart
Natural Himalayan Salt Chunks
Approximately 1/2 lb -
$
5.00
Add to Cart
"Witch Switch" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
5.50
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Limited Quantity - Only 3 left!
Spotted Pheasant Feathers
Set of 5 Feathers -
Was
$3.00
- now
$
2.40
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 1 left!
Peekaboo Cat Witch Hat
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 1 left!
Golden Feathered Witch Hat
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
"Infinity Dragon" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
15.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 1 left!
Flying Dragon Witch Hat
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
"Durrow" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
20.00
Sorry, temporarily out of stock.
View Item
▸
Tumbled Carnelian Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
6.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
"Cead Mile Failte" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
20.00
Sorry, temporarily out of stock.
View Item
▸
Cat Pentagram Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Tumbled Howlite Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 1 left!
Midnight Moonflower Witch Hat
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 2 left!
Luna Moth Witch Hat
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Limited
Only 1 left!
Zig Zag Zest Witch Hat
$
45.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Add to Cart
Dark Rose Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
12.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Butterfly Ring
Available in sizes
Sizes
4-12
-
Sterling Silver -
$
47.00
5
stars
(
6
reviews)
Choose Size
▸
"My Cauldron" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
6.00
Add to Cart
The Moon Was Full Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
7.00
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Butterfly Pendant
Sterling Silver -
$
79.00
5
stars
(
10
reviews)
Choose Gem
▸
Silver Celtic Butterfly Earrings
Sterling Silver -
$
41.00
5
stars
(
2
reviews)
Add to Cart
Do No Harm Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Remember the Rule Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
7.00
Add to Cart
Celtic Cat Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
11.00
Add to Cart
House Rules Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
6.00
Sorry, temporarily out of stock.
View Item
▸
Silver Celtic Moon Ring
Available in sizes
Sizes
4-12
-
Sterling Silver -
$
31.00
5
stars
(
11
reviews)
Choose Size
▸
Silver Labradorite Dragon's Claw Ring
Available in sizes
Sizes
7-12
-
Sterling Silver -
$
85.00
Choose Size
▸
Tumbled Vesuvianite Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
4.00
Add to Cart
"Wild One" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
$
22.00
Add to Cart
Clearance!
Limited Quantity - Only 2 left!
"Pegasus" Cross Stitch Pattern
Cross Stitch Pattern Only -
Was
$22.00
- now
$
16.50
Add to Cart
Tumbled Bloodstone Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
7.00
5
stars
(
5
reviews)
Add to Cart
Bronze Celtic Axehead Pendant
$
20.00
5
stars
(
5
reviews)
Add to Cart
New!
Tumbled Lepidolite Gemstones
$
6.00
Add to Cart
Tumbled Rhodonite Gemstones
set of 3 stones -
$
12.00
4
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Silver Petite Celtic Butterfly Pendant
Sterling Silver -
$
29.00
5
stars
(
1
review)
Add to Cart
Silver Celtic Key Pendant
Sterling Silver -
$
22.00
5
stars
(
2
reviews)
Add to Cart